Making engagement meaningful in Helsinki
A growing number of nations and cities are seeking to involve citizens in decision-making, says @tommilaitio #FindingLegitimacyShare article
How is the city of #Helsinki involving citizens in decision-making? @tommilaitio explains all... #FindingLegitimacyShare article
Citizen engagement is essential for legitimacy but it is an ongoing process, says @tommilaitio #FindingLegitimacyShare article
There is no doubt that citizen engagement is essential for legitimacy. With trust in government declining around the world, we see a growing number of nations and cities working to increase the participation of citizens in decision-making processes and in all aspects of public life.
For Helsinki, the concept of citizen engagement and cocreation of public policy is not new. The city has successfully been using participatory design since 2012, from reshaping museum experiences to city bikes projects. Last year, over 12,000 teenagers in all of Helsinki's districts took part in a participatory budgeting process of their neighbourhood´s leisure activities. Moreover, Helsinki was the first city in the world to appoint a chief design officer, and it has been a world leader in moving to an open data approach.
Alongside a major restructuring of City Hall and the development and launch of Helsinki's City Strategy 2017-2021, the city recently introduced a new engagement model, aimed at establishing a continuous dialogue between the city and its residents. “Each resident of Helsinki has the right to feel they are a true Helsinki citizen and to do something significant for their community. In Helsinki, it is easy to be of help to others.”
Engagement is a high priority for Helsinki, and City Hall has gained valuable insights into how it can be made meaningful for residents as well as for the city's employees.
Engagement begins with a good understanding of people's needs
The starting point for any successful citizen engagement is understanding the needs of citizens. Engagement means more than thinking in averages; it requires acknowledging citizens as individuals with different interests, skills, needs and ambitions.
To ensure that the diversity of people's demands is reflected in the new engagement model, the city of Helsinki embarked on a two-year-long cocreation journey with residents, community organisations, and Helsinki's business community. Three founding principles for engagement emerged from this process. Firstly, use the experience and expertise of the community; secondly, increase people's ability to live a free life and make choices; and thirdly, make participation more equal across the city in terms of access as well as empowering vulnerable groups.
Engagement is successful when participants feel valued
Tone and timing are crucial drivers of successful engagement. To engage a representative and diverse proportion of the population, government needs to use the right language and find a way to present the problem in a way that resonates with its citizens.
Engagement needs to happen at the onset of a problem, at a stage in the process where citizens feel that they can truly shape policy formulation. It loses its meaning when citizens are merely asked to validate existing ideas. It is also important for government to feed back to the people involved, and let them know how their inputs have affected processes and outcomes.
Implementing the new model in City Hall and with frontline staff
Developing a new engagement model, however, does not immediately translate into better engagement. The city of Helsinki understood that in order to turn words into actions, more had to be done to get its 41,000 civil servants on board. To achieve that, the city partnered with design agency Hellon to develop a Participation Game for its employees. The aim of this interactive board game is to encourage city staff to think creatively about how they can improve the dialogue with citizens, without any predefined strategies or methods.
The game is usually played with a team of 10-15 players and consists of four phases. It begins with an assessment of the engagement situation and the stakeholder groups, and is aimed at developing a clear understanding of who is involved and what their interests are. In the second phase, participants evaluate engagement methods that have been employed in the past, trying to identify what worked and what didn't.
The third phase includes a set of flash cards describing the different engagement and feedback tools that support participants in translating their ideas into action. The final phase of the game involves choosing up to three new methods to be tested as potential solutions to the identified issues. The process is overseen by a trained facilitator, who ensures that the relevant information about engagement is extracted and that progress is made on defining a development plan for the selected solution. The game takes 90 to 120 minutes to complete.
The game has received extremely positive and enthusiastic feedback from users at all levels of all City Hall's departments. It has now been played hundreds of times across Helsinki - by teachers, nurses, youth workers, librarians and museum curators, as well as the executive teams in City Hall. It has inspired them and helped them to think outside the box about how to reach different audience groups. Even when some staff members have initially been sceptical about the idea of playing a board game, they have come away feeling that the game helped them in making choices and gaining new skills.
Legitimacy: a continuous journey
Helsinki has made extraordinary progress in fostering meaningful collaboration with its citizens. The new engagement model contributes to what is already a high level of trust in Finnish institutions. But the model is not static, and the city recognises that strengthening legitimacy is an ongoing process. The model will be adapted over time to the evolving needs and aspirations of the community, and City Hall will continue to think of new ways to engage with the people of Helsinki.
What is legitimacy to you? Where do you see legitimacy working well? How governments work with citizens to build legitimacy is a big question for CPI.
Find out how to get involved in our Finding Legitimacy project
- Finding legitimacy - CPI is starting a global conversation for better outcomes. Nadine Smith introduces a new research programme about legitimacy from the Centre for Public Impact.
- Introducing the Finding Legitimacy regional champions. We meet the regional champions of CPI's #FindingLegitimacy project
- Why you cannot fix legitimacy but you can mend it. How can governments reconnect with their citizens? Nadine Smith explains why there is is no catch-all fix but instead a continuous journey of improvement
- If no news is good news, what is fake news? With fake news increasingly part of the public discourse, Nadine Smith examines how governments can start to strengthen its own credibility rating.
- Public impact in a post-truth world. Governments have struggled for years to understand that people's perceptions of life are very often their reality, says Adrian Brown, who suggests that “post-truth” can simply mean “truth” from a different vantage point
- Why we shouldn't panic over post-truth. Nadine Smith explains why policymakers should understand how to adapt messages so that people feel connected to them.